Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Was it right for Johnny to kill Bob? Was there something else he could have done to help Ponyboy?

2 comments:

Meagan McKinstry said...

Johnny killed Bob in a moment of desperation when he thought Ponyboy was going to drown. He did save his friend’s life, but he ended another’s life at the same time, so that was not the right thing to do. Johnny killed Bob because his extreme fear of the Socs clouded his thinking. If he had been less scared, he could have tried to fight the Socs away instead of killing one of them, or even better, he could have tried to get help, which would have eliminated violence. Johnny acted rashly, and if he had lived, I know he would have made a better choice the next time.

Anonymous said...

February 12, 2007

Johnny had to kill Bob if he wanted Ponyboy to live. It was the only way and Johnny really cared about Ponyboy. There was nothing else that Johnny could do. It was sort of an instinct for him. Johnny soon probably realized that his actions eventually got him killed. If he was still alive, he would have thought twice about doing what he did.